Universidade de Lisboa Repositório da Universidade de Lisboa

Repositório da Universidade de Lisboa >
Faculdade de Letras (FL) >
Centro de Estudos Comparatistas (FL - CEComp) >
FL - CEComp - Livros e Capítulos de Livros >

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10451/5854

Título: Polishing Papers for Publication: Palimpsests or Procrustean Beds?
Autor: Bennett, Karen
McKenny, John
Palavras-chave: academic discourse
humanities
Portuguese
English
research articles corpus
Issue Date: 2010
Editora: Continuum
Citação: McKenny, John & Bennett, Karen.‘Polishing Papers for Publication: Palimpsests or Procrustean Beds?’. In New Trends in Corpora and Language Learning, Ana Frankenburg-Garcia, Lynn Flowerdew & Guy Aston (Eds.), Continuum. 2010.
Resumo: This chapter is the result of a collaboration between a corpus linguist and a polisher or reviser of academic papers written by established Portuguese academics. The aim was to examine the hypothesis that not only lexical and syntactic features, but also phraseological and discourse features of L1 may be transferred into the Portuguese researchers’ L2 writing, thereby undermining the “naturalness” of the writing and raising an (invisible?) obstacle to international publication. The corpus (Portac), which consisted of some 113,000 running words of English academic prose, was created from texts that had been presented to the language consultant for revision prior to submission for publication. After correction of superficial grammatical and spelling errors, it was tagged for Part of Speech (CLAWS7) and semantic field (USAS) using WMatrix2 (Rayson 2003), and interrogated for the presence of certain discourse features using Wmatrix2 and Wordsmith Tools (Scott 1999). The findings were then compared with those of a control corpus (Controlit) of published articles written by L1 academics in a similar field. The results reveal significant overuse of certain features by Portuguese academics, and a corresponding underuse of others, suggesting a marked disparity in the value attributed to those features by the two cultures. This, it is suggested, may be due to differences in epistemological outlook, which raises issues of both a practical and an ideological nature for the language reviser.
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10451/5854
ISBN: 978-1-4411-5996-0
Versão do Editor: http://www.continuumbooks.com/search/default.aspx?Text=New%20Trends%20in%20Corpora%20and%20Language%20Learning
Appears in Collections:FL - CEComp - Livros e Capítulos de Livros

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
Polishing Papers for Publication.pdf6,19 MBAdobe PDFView/Open
Statistics
FacebookTwitterDeliciousLinkedInDiggGoogle BookmarksMySpaceOrkut
Formato BibTex mendeley Endnote Logotipo do DeGóis 

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

 

  © Universidade de Lisboa / SIBUL
Alameda da Universidade | Cidade Universitária | 1649-004 Lisboa | Portugal
Tel. +351 217967624 | Fax +351 217933624 | repositorio@reitoria.ul.pt - Feedback - Statistics
DeGóis
  Estamos no RCAAP Governo Português separator Ministério da Educação e Ciência   Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia

Financiado por:

POS_C UE